Curtis Island Community Vision Report

June 2025

Photo: Jon Cunningham, Compass Light Productions

Click here to download a pdf version of this report.

During the winter of 2025, more than eighty Camden residents participated in the Curtis Island Community Visioning process.  Two workshops were held, and many others completed the Visioning Survey Workbook on the our website, all answering these three questions:

Thinking ahead 5 years, what is your vision for Curtis Island?

When you think of Curtis Island, what do you cherish or are most proud of? 

What are your worries and concerns?

Each participant’s written thoughts were transcribed, and common “themes” emerged from each question. From this, a collective vision was formed.  This report shares the most frequently stated themes from each question with direct quotes from participants. The Curtis Island Lighthouse Foundation continues to welcome individual vision statements which become the foundation from which the preservation and restoration of the Curtis Island Light Station emerges. Read on…

Michael Skaling, President
Curtis Island Lighthouse Foundation
Michael@curtisisland.org

Collective Community Vision of Curtis Island—In Five Years…

Curtis Island Light Station stands as a beacon of serenity, history, and community spirit, cherished by the people of Camden and beyond. Our vision for the future of Curtis Island is rooted in the preservation of its natural beauty, historical significance, and the unique sense of tranquility it offers. We will maintain the island as a sanctuary where the past and present coexist harmoniously, providing a peaceful retreat for reflection and connection with nature.

We envision Curtis Island as a place where the historical structures, including the iconic lighthouse, are preserved and restored. These buildings will serve as living museums, offering insights into the maritime heritage of Camden and the lives of the lighthouse keepers who once tended the light. Through careful restoration, we will ensure that these structures remain a testament to the island's rich history, accessible to all who wish to learn and appreciate their significance.

Access to Curtis Island will be thoughtfully managed to maintain its serenity and prevent overuse. We will promote sustainable practices, encouraging visitors to reach the island through non-motorized means, preserving its peaceful atmosphere. By limiting the number of visitors and ensuring that access is respectful of the island's natural environment, we will protect its fragile ecosystems and ensure that Curtis Island remains a haven for wildlife and a place of solitude for all who visit.

Education and community involvement are central to our vision. We will foster a strong educational component, offering programs that engage school children, historians, and community members in the island's stewardship. Curtis Island will become a place of learning, where the importance of conservation, global warming, and historic preservation is shared with future generations. To ensure everyone has the chance to experience the island, transportation for local residents who do not have access to small boat transportation will be transported to island on selected days during the summer. Through these planned island trips, volunteer opportunities, and community-led initiatives, a sense of shared responsibility and pride in the island's upkeep will be cultivated.

Financial sustainability is crucial to the long-term preservation of Curtis Island. We will establish a robust financial foundation, exploring fundraising opportunities and partnerships to support ongoing maintenance and restoration efforts. A collaborative governance model, involving both the Town of Camden and the Curtis Island Lighthouse Foundation, will ensure transparent and inclusive decision-making, balancing public access with the need for preservation.

In essence, our vision for Curtis Island is one of balance—between preservation and access, history and modernity, solitude and community. We are committed to ensuring that Curtis Island remains a cherished asset for future generations, a place where the beauty of nature and the echoes of history can be experienced and appreciated by all. Through collective effort and shared stewardship, the island will continue to be a symbol of Camden's heritage and a sanctuary of peace, reflection, and education.

Most Common Vision Themes and Quotes

Preservation and Restoration

A strong desire to preserve the historical and natural aspects of Curtis Island including the four structures that make-up the light station.  Restoration efforts should maintain the island's historical integrity while ensuring the buildings are in good condition.

"I envision it as a historically preserved entity – the environment would be totally natural but kept trimmed."

"I envision the town community realizing the asset they have in Curtis Island from the park-like setting to the historic buildings.

“Buildings preserved as a museum to learn the importance of lighthouses and the life of the lightkeepers.”

“I see all the buildings historically restored.”

“The lighthouse and support buildings are fully restored.”

“Buildings restored with limited access sustainable practice with a light keeper managed by citizens with limited government group."

Limited and Managed Access

Opinions vary on access, with some advocating for limited access to preserve the island’s serenity while others suggest controlled public access with educational and recreational opportunities. Many participants emphasized the importance of controlling access to the island to prevent overuse and maintain its tranquility. Suggestions include limiting the number of visitors and using non-motorized boats for access.

"Access would be limited to the island, so the island does not get overrun or misused."

"Access remains as it is now – swim, row, sail, and dinghy not involving a dock."

“A safe and accessible landing with well maintained, safe, and presentable buildings.”

“Increased visitors to the island will increase support of the island.”

Education and Cultural Heritage

There is a strong interest in involving the community in the island's management and using it as an educational resource. This includes programs for school children and opportunities for community members to volunteer.

"A strong well-designed educational component that includes a formal program/set of classes.”

“Students understand the need for “light touch” on the island.”

“The island has become an ecological teaching ground for other communities.”

“Education programs with school children involved, as well as older historians."

"I would like to see caretakers for 8 to 10 months full-time educational programs to help support building fund."

Environmental Protection and Sustainability

Protecting the island's natural environment and addressing climate change impacts are key concerns. Participants envision sustainable practices and minimal infrastructure to preserve the island's ecosystem.

"Protect as best as can from climate change coming – sea rise and storms."

"The ecology of the flora and fauna have been sufficiently protected while still allowing human access and enjoyment."

Financial Sustainability

Establishing a financial foundation or endowment to ensure the island's long-term maintenance and preservation is a priority. This includes exploring fundraising opportunities and partnerships.

“Investing in Curtis Island is investing in our community’s future, ensuring that this treasure remains vi brant and accessible.”

"Fundraising needs to be expanded to include an endowment that is critical to fund  long-term maintenance."

"$1 million endowment for maintenance CILF in charge of buildings."

Management and Governance

The management and governance of Curtis Island are central to its future preservation and accessibility. There is a strong emphasis on creating a balanced approach that involves both the Town of Camden and the Curtis Island Lighthouse Foundation (CILF). The community envisions a collaborative governance model that leverages the strengths of both public and private entities. This model aims to ensure that the island's historical, cultural, and natural resources are preserved while maintaining public access and engagement. The governance structure is expected to be transparent, inclusive, and sustainable, with a focus on long-term stewardship and community involvement.  This theme highlights the community's desire for a governance model that is both effective and inclusive, ensuring that Curtis Island remains a cherished and well-maintained asset for future generations.

"I would like to have a committee of townspeople/or a foundation that has sufficient funds to be the body which makes decisions regarding the island. Perhaps the town will be out of the decision-making process."

"The island thrives under the stewardship of a dedicated committee, supported by local volunteers and the Curtis Island Lighthouse Foundation."

"Functional public/private partnership between Camden and the private entities that can raise funds for specific needs or manage an endowment to cover ongoing and occasional costs."

Community Involvement

Curtis Island reflects the collective engagement and shared responsibility of Camden residents and visitors in preserving, maintaining, and enjoying the island's natural beauty and historical significance, fostering a sense of connection and stewardship.

"I love that it is available for everyone to see, but it feels particularly loved by locals that hold it in their hearts and is meaningful to them."

" Everyone enjoys the island; it’s like the one common thread that everyone shares about a place."

"Curtis Island is a getaway for me. A place to relax, enjoy nature and the ocean, take a walk to the lighthouse, maybe go for a swim."

"Public access due to town ownership, the paths around and through the island."

"To me, Curtis Island is special because it’s a place to which locals and visitors alike can get away from the growing hustle and bustle of Camden’s downtown."

Cherished aspects of Curtis Island or areas most proud of?

Curtis Island is a cherished gem for the community of Camden, offering a unique blend of serenity, adventure, and historical significance. Its proximity to town makes it accessible, yet the journey to reach it adds a sense of adventure that enhances its allure. The island's rich maritime history and iconic lighthouse are treasured by locals and visitors alike, serving as a reminder of its long maritime history.  The natural beauty of Curtis Island, with its unspoiled landscapes and breathtaking views, provides a peaceful retreat for those seeking solace. Moreover, the island fosters a sense of community, offering a shared space where people can connect, create memories, and appreciate the simple pleasures of life.

Most Common Themes and Quotes

Serenity and Solitude

Many participants cherish the tranquility and peacefulness of Curtis Island. The island offers a unique escape from the hustle and bustle of modern life, providing a serene environment for reflection and relaxation.

"The beauty and the solitude make Curtis Island a magical place. You have to see it firsthand, walk the island and understand how much of an asset Curtis Island is to the town and area."

"Silence, distance (metaphorical) from modern life. Freedom of access. A place to sit and gaze at the ocean away from everything."

“The natural beauty is what draws me out to the island.  The peace and quiet of nature is what keeps me there.”

Accessibility and Adventure

Curtis Island is valued for its accessibility, yet the journey to reach it adds a sense of adventure. The island is close enough to town for easy access but requires effort to reach, which enhances its allure.

"It is so near to Camden, so it is very accessible and gives an opportunity to those without a large boat to experience a little bit of an island experience.”

"Since access is only by boat, the 'park' aspect becomes more special – feels remote – isolated – more of an adventure."

“I value that it is both easy and hard to get to, not far to row, kayak, canoe, or swim.” 

Historical Significance

The island is a symbol of Camden's maritime history and heritage. Participants emphasize the importance of preserving the lighthouse and other historical structures to maintain the island's historical narrative.

"Curtis Island is a tremendously important symbol representing important history and the traditions of another era."

"It’s one of the most iconic lighthouses on the northeastern coast, and it would be a travesty if it were not preserved for future generations."

“Key aspects of the town’s history, and an important landmark.  Part of Camden’s identity.”

Natural Beauty and Environment

The natural landscape of Curtis Island, including its trails, beaches, and views, is highly valued. Participants appreciate the island's unspoiled nature and the opportunity to connect with the environment.

"Cherish the quiet, the vast views of the sky, considering the tide, the water when it’s warmed over the sand on the incoming tide, it’s unspoiled nature."

"Curtis Island is a getaway for me. A place to relax enjoy nature and the ocean, take a walk to the lighthouse, maybe go for a swim."

“The beauty of the island, peacefulness once you are on the island, the history of the lighthouse and Camden history of lighthouse keepers.”

“Beauty of the island and lighthouse seen from the Camden Hills, from many points around the harbor.”

Preservation and Sustainability

There is a strong desire to preserve the island’s natural and historical features for future generations while maintaining its simplicity.

“We need to restore the buildings and maintain the island for the future.  These are the features that are most important.”

“Buildings need to be fixed up – reflect poorly on the Town.”

“Preservation should be the top goal.”

“I love that people like this organization, care about restoration and preservation, and not letting it get rundown.”

Community and Shared Experience

Curtis Island is seen as a communal space that fosters a sense of connection among locals and visitors. It is a place where people can share experiences and create lasting memories.

"We are always so proud to show it off as a local gem and very unique feature for our tiny town." 

Iconic Landmark

Curtis Island is an iconic symbol of Camden, serving as a visual and cultural landmark for the community and visitors.

"It is the eminent entrance feature from the harbor much like the Camden Public Library is for the Town.”

“An iconic feature of Camden’s landscape that has welcomed – guided visitors to town for centuries.”

“I value its position as the protector of, and portal to, Camden Harbor.”

Worries, concerns for Curtis Island and its Light Station?

The concerns and worries about Curtis Island Light Station revolve around the delicate balance between preserving its historical and natural integrity while allowing for public enjoyment. Key themes include the potential overuse and impact of tourism, the necessity for ongoing preservation and maintenance of historic structures, and the challenges of providing balanced access without compromising the island's unique qualities. Governance and funding are critical issues, with a need for clear responsibility and sustainable financial support. Additionally, protecting the island's environment and wildlife remains a priority, as increased human activity poses risks to its fragile ecosystems. Overall, the community seeks to ensure that Curtis Island remains a cherished and accessible asset for future generations.

Most Common Themes and Quotes

Overuse and Tourism Impact

Many individuals express concern that increased tourism and visitor numbers could overwhelm the island's natural environment and infrastructure. There is a fear that the island could become a victim of its own success, leading to degradation of its unique qualities.

“I worry about too much people traffic. I worry that good decisions are not made concerning the preservation aspects, about how to control usage, so the ecology of the island is not corrupted."

"Becoming a victim of its own success, i.e., a tourist hotspot and consequent increase in visitor numbers."

“I worry that it will be loved to death.”

Preservation and Maintenance

There is a strong emphasis on the need for preserving the historic structures and maintaining the island's natural beauty. Concerns include the potential neglect of restoration efforts and the impact of climate change on the island's infrastructure.

"The concern is that the buildings will not be restored and maintained.”

“I worry that the house will fall into further disrepair.”

“The wear and tear on the buildings and grounds without upkeep and caretakers.”

"It would be endlessly sad to see the island's buildings break down, lack of care."

“Storm damage and accelerated physical deterioration due to insufficient annual upkeep.”

“I am worried about the condition of the building [Light Keeper’s House] it looks like it needs some maintenance.”

Access and Infrastructure

Access to the island is a significant concern, with discussions around the need for balanced access that allows enjoyment without compromising the island's integrity. There are also worries about the adequacy of current infrastructure to support visitors.

"Unless you own a boat, you never get to see the lighthouse; it’s become disconnected from the town."

"I’m worried that public access will be too limited."

“Too many people accessing it.  It’s good that you have to kayak or row to get there.”

“Access changing/being removed/more difficult/lack of public access.”

“Our greatest fear that it [does not] stay an open, welcoming, and  free-to-visit public space.”

Governance and Funding

Concerns about governance and funding focus on the need for clear responsibility and sustainable financial support for the island's upkeep. There is apprehension about the Town's commitment and the potential for commercialization to fund maintenance.

"Concerns: saving Curtis Island, and its light station – hopefully with interest and meetings like this, it will be considered an important feature of Camden."

"Sustained appropriate funding for historic preservation."

“Concerned about funding going forward with so many other projects.”

“Worries include lack of funding, disrepair, or privatization.”

“Lack of proactive involvement by town.”

“Concern of how Curtis Island will be used and managed.”

Environmental and Wildlife Protection

Protecting the island's environment and wildlife is a priority for many. There are worries about the impact of increased human activity on the island's fragile ecosystems and the need to preserve its natural state.

"Trail erosion from overuse.”

“Eagles have been disturbed in the harbor and need protection to give them the best chance
to raise young."

"I’m concerned about what increased access to the public will do to the island's habitat."

“With more frequent storm surges and the possibility of a possible 4-foot rise of sea level.”

Cultural and Historical Preservation

The importance of maintaining the island’s historical and cultural significance without altering its character.

"I would like the island and its essential building to be restored but not altered significantly.”

“It should not be allowed to disintegrate.”

“I’m worried that we will not preserve the historic buildings and that we will not document the history.”

Thank you for taking time to read and absorb the community vision of the Curtis Island Light Station and for help in restoring Curtis Island for generations to come.